In today's Opinion Journal, Daniel Henninger takes a look at the blogosphere and asks, "Are you people all crazy?" Well, not exactly, but close. He points out that there are some very odd things happening out there in interweb space. The thing he worries about most is disinhibition. (We've mentioned before that the lack of non-verbal cues leads some people to go completely over the top when blogging or commenting).
Example: The Web site currently famous for enabling and aggregating millions of personal blogs is called MySpace.com. If you opened its "blogs" page this week, the first thing you saw was a blogger's video of a guy swilling beer and sticking his middle finger through a car window. Right below that were two blogs by women in their underwear.
In our time, it has generally been thought bad and unhealthy to "repress" inhibitions. Spend a few days inside the new world of personal blogs, however, and one might want to revisit the repression issue.
The human species has spent several hundred thousand years sorting through which emotions and marginal neuroses to keep under control and which to release. Now, with a keyboard, people overnight are "free" to unburden and unhinge themselves continuously and exponentially. One researcher quotes the entry-page of a teenage girl's blog: "You are now entering my world. My pain. My mind. My thoughts. My emotions. Enter with caution and an open mind."
An interesting thought. Are we, in fact, losing our inhibitions and, by extension, some of our civility and and ability to control ourselves? Well, I think the answer is: some people are. Henninger cites some of the rank behavior on some comment threads. There are people who obviously act as if they are out of control. Now whether they would continue that behavior away from the computer is another thing altogether.
At the risk of enabling, does the Internet mean that all the rest of us are being made unwitting participants in the personal and political life of, um, crazy people? As populist psychiatry, maybe this is a good thing; the Web allows large numbers of people to contribute to others' therapy. It takes a village.
But researchers note that the isolation of Web life results in many missed social cues. It is similar to the experience of riding an indoor roller coaster, what is known in that industry as a "dark ride." This dark ride could be a very long one.
Well, I think it may be a bit to soon to predict the end of the world as we know it. (Sorry, I'll bet you could hear R.E.M. just then couldn't you?) But I think Henninger has a valid point here. He may also be struggling to grasp the whole concept of the blogosphere.
Read the whole thing.