The Worst Of The American Left

Untitled document

Ross Kaminsky explains that the behavior of the junior jackboots club at Columbia University when the stormed the stage to silence the founder of the Minuteman Project is nothing new to Columbia. It has been a pattern for a long time.

As a graduate of Columbia College ('87) and the son of a Columbia graduate, I have some perspective on the school and the history of student behavior there. Sadly, nothing has changed in the over 45 years which include my father's time at Columbia, my time there, and the recent "Minuteman protests."

Around 1960, Ayn Rand was invited to speak at Columbia. My father went to hear her. She was shouted down and, unable to address the crowd, left the podium after properly scolding the students for their bad manners. The protesters spent much of their time railing against the evils of capitalism and liberty.

In about 1985, there were protests and scuffles as students barricaded Hamilton Hall to demand the University divest itself of investments in companies which did business in South Africa. The protesters spent much of their time railing against the evils of capitalism and liberty, with somewhat more physical violence than had been seen 25 years earlier.

And now, 20 years after those protests, I see Columbia students act aggressively, irresponsibly, and disgustingly, trying to silence another invited speaker.

A letter to the editor of the Columbia Spectator on October 9th as well as the staff editorial on the same date are informative: The "message from the protesters", apparently written by a senior majoring in economics, goes out of its way to misstate the goals of the Minutemen (of whom I am not a huge fan, for the record). The writer also makes the typical leftist radical mistake of calling everything she disagrees with "fascist", a rather silly error for anyone but especially a senior economics major.

The writer tries to create a moral equivalence between the protesters' directly inciting violence against an invited speaker and what she considers to be offensive speech or policy goals of the Minutemen or some of its members. She misses the basic point of America: Political speech, even if you don't like it, is precisely what the First Amendment was written to protect. Violence against a speaker is unacceptable.

Everything you really need to know about the protesters is contained in this sentence: "Shame on the College Republicans for inviting this fascist thug and provoking such outrage on our campus." In other words, the act of inviting a controversial speaker is worse than violence against that speaker…oh, and the speaker must be a "fascist thug" because he doesn't agree with the writer's left-wing sensibilities which are typical of Columbia students.

Her protests that "this is not an issue of free speech" makes it all that much clearer that that is exactly what the issue is. The protesters do not have an "equal right" to shout down a speaker, much less to assault him or his entourage. The right answer…the only answer acceptable in our country…is to let him speak and then set up your own event to tell everyone why he was wrong.

Kaminsky is spot on here. Read the whole thing.

This entry was posted in Left Wing, The Ivory Tower. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to The Worst Of The American Left

  1. syn says:

    I’m going to the speech tonight given by Walid Shoebot at Columbia. An ex-palestinian ex-terrorist speaking at the a pro-terrorist palestine university should be interesting.

    Security is tight however, entrance is body only without bags, purses etc

  2. It looks like the left is beginning to steal from the Muslim playbook:

    “Shame on the College Republicans for inviting this fascist thug and provoking such outrage on our campus.”

    Sounds an awful lot like the Muslim reaction when someone says that Islam is violent — they riot and protest until a few people lay dead.

    It all reminds me of a drunk guy standing over his wife with a black eye, screaming, “see what you made me do to you!”

Comments are closed.