Kimberley Strassel, writing in the Opinion Journal, point out the blatant political posturing that is driving the recent ruckus over allowing Canadian drugs to be imported. The vote in the Senate failed a few days ago. The media reported all that. What the media is silent on is the failure of Americans to be actually interested in obtaining Canadian drugs.
Listen to Maine Sen. Olympia Snowe discuss importing drugs from Canada, and you'll hear endless happy talk about "more competitive prices," "substantial savings" and how "crucial" reimportation is to "the American consumer." What you won't hear Ms. Snowe mention much is the drug-import program of Portland, Maine.
Interesting that, since Portland was one of those cities that gained notoriety a few years back for defying federal law and setting up a Canada import program that it promised would save its thousands of city employees and their dependents a bundle on drugs. Three years in, it has attracted all of 350 participants.
That was also the flame-out fate of a statewide plan by Gov. John Baldacci to empower the Penobscot Indian Nation to build a distribution center to import price-controlled Canadian drugs for some 325,000 uninsured and underinsured Mainers. The tribe in February unceremoniously closed the program (which never got its hands on Canadian drugs, but morphed into a domestic mail-order business), having attracted just 3,000 Medicaid recipients.
Programs all over the country that were started up with enormous fanfare and positive press pontifications are already either closed or failing. Because, it turns out, that while politicians may be getting lots of positive press for their efforts, Americans are not really interested.
If anything, Portland is a success compared to the more high-profile state programs that got rolling in 2004. When Illinois Gov. Rod Blagojevich introduced his I-Save-RX program, which was initially joined by neighboring Wisconsin, he dramatically declared that "the nearly 13 million people who live in Illinois and the more than five million people who live in Wisconsin will have the opportunity to save hundreds–and in some cases even thousands–of dollars each year on the high cost of their medicine." Mr. Blagoevich spent nearly $1 million in taxpayer dollars developing it, including some 500 state workers from two dozen agencies who spent 5,600 hours flacking the program.
All this caused Illinois Auditor General William Holland to get curious about just how much benefit this wonder program was producing, and last fall he issued a stunning report. Over 19 months of operation, a grand total of 3,689 Illinois residents had used the program, which equals approximately 0.02% of the population. Results from the four other participating states were even more laughably dismal. Wisconsin had 321 people use the program; Kansas 267; Missouri 460; and Vermont 217. Mr. Holland also noted that the program was, er, illegal, and that the state had failed to implement quality control.
Things haven't been much rosier for Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty, a Republican who felt it expedient to throw over the U.S. drug industry in favor of a few populist headlines. Mr. Pawlenty promised in 2003 that his Minnesota RxConnect program would serve some 700,000 people. A representative from Minnesota's department of human services explained to me this week that the state (conveniently) does not break out the number of people who use its program. But according to its latest statistics, Minnesota RxConnect last month filled a total of 138 prescriptions. That's for the whole state. Programs like those in Springfield, Mass., have simply closed.
This has a lot more to do with a union-driven agenda than it has with any real issue. In point of fact, Wal-Mart is selling generic drugs even cheaper than the much-ballyhooed Canadian ones. (I'm not sure that program has gone completely nation-wide yet, however). What you have operating here is political pandering to a union agenda, populist posturing by politicians and the media cooperating by playing dumb to the failures of these programs to attract American consumers.