Jun 25 2007
When The Circus Comes To Town
There are always clowns. But in this case, the clown lost. The judge who filed a $54 million lawsuit over a pair of pants not only lost, but he is getting hit with the legal fees for the people he sued. And he may lose his job as a judge over the ridiculous lawsuit.
In a verdict that surprised no one, except perhaps the plaintiff himself, a D.C. Superior Court judge denied Roy Pearson the big payday he claimed was his due.
Delivering her decision in writing, Judge Judith Bartnoff wrote 23 pages dissecting and dismissing Pearson's claim that he was defrauded by the owners of Custom Cleaners and their "Satisfaction Guaranteed" sign.
"A reasonable consumer would not interpret 'Satisfaction Guaranteed' to mean that a merchant is required to satisfy a customer's unreasonable demands or to accede to demands that the merchant has reasonable grounds to dispute," the ruling said. " . . . The plaintiff is not entitled to any relief whatsoever."
It was a pointed rebuke of Pearson's claim, and came with an order to pay the cleaners' court costs. But even bigger troubles may loom for Pearson.
Financially, he could soon be on the hook for tens of thousands of dollars in legal fees incurred by the owners of Customer Cleaners. Attorneys for the Chungs have said they will seek such payments, as well as sanctions against Pearson for bringing the lawsuit. Bartnoff said in her ruling that she would decide those issues after both sides have filed their motions, counter-motions and legal briefs.
Professionally, Pearson could find himself out of his $96,000-a-year job as an administrative law judge for the District government.
All that is certain right now is that he won't be getting the multi-million dollar payout he demanded when he filed suit in 2005 against Soo Chung and her husband, the owners of Custom Cleaners.Originally, Pearson had asked for $65 million, but by the time the case went to trial two weeks ago, Pearson had lowered his demand to $54 million.
Frankly, I hope he does lose his job. This guy is disgrace to the legal profession. Even trial lawyers are seriously angry with this guy according to reports. He's giving an already loathed profession an even worse name - and that really takes some doing.
3 Responses to “When The Circus Comes To Town”






I still think that they should have made a prime time Judge Judy special just for this case. I think he deserved a good tongue-lashing as well as the ramifications outlined above.
BTW, did he cry this time, too? (Sorry, I couldn’t resist going there just because I found it so ludicrous before.)
Actually, I hope they let him work just long enough to ay off the cleaners’ legal bills. I saw a local article and they were well over $100K
Oaxaca, Mexico: I’ve found the pants!…
Why didn’t he just check with me first?…